Battery Health: The FUD, and the Truth

What’s the Truth?

Most production EV batteries are warrantied between 7-10 years and from 70,000 to 100,000 miles. For example:

ManufacturerWarranty GivenSource
TeslaMinimum 8 years, 100,000 Miles
Nissan8 years, 100,000 miles
MG8 Years, 100,000 miles
VW8 Years, 100,000 miles
BMW8 Years. 100,000 miles
Table outlining battery warranties of main EV manufacturers.

The warranty limits are based on the energy it will carry when it was new and fully charged. This is generally 70-80% capacity They will work after the warranty period (just like an ICE engine).

As a side note, the above manufacturers that offer a engine warranty tends to only offer a 3 year 60,000 mile on the engine.

Fact is that a manufacturer will not offer a warranty (on any item, let alone a car), if they can be assured that the vast majority of cars will not have issues. This is extremely important.

What’s 100,000 miles?

According to a MOT study, the average mileage of a UK motorist is around 7400 miles . Therefore:

  1. These batteries will do 56,000 miles on average before the time on the warranty ends
  2. Or alternatively need to cover 12,500 miles a year to achieve the 100,000 miles. For most people, this is unlikely, although not impossible.

What about after 100,000 miles?

Regarding data, there are not many peer-reviewed studies I can find on this.

There are multiple data entries from different sources which identify that most batteries will maintain at worst 80% health for at least 5 years In fact, after 9 years, according to this study, on average the battery is fully working and at 85% degradation .

In general, battery replacements are not as popular as once imagined. In fact Nissan believe that the vast majority of batteries placed into cars are still inside cars

Tesla (and many other manufacturers with active battery management), are likely to fare significantly better . The vast majority of manufacturers (with the exception of Nissan with only their LEAF), have thermal battery management.

This is different to ICE vehicles. Although they both do decrease in performance over time , unlike a petrol and diesel engine, this is a permanent degradation. It cannot get better without a change of the cells in the battery pack.

What Can Be Done?

There are methods to bring back the battery health which do not involve replacing the entire pack, including replacing individual cells , which will be significantly cheaper.

In the case of this video, this Nissan Leaf had reached 120,000 miles and was abused with multiple rapid charges per day.

In the unlikely event the capacity drops below the minimum warrantied capacity, the pack will be refurbished (to get back up to 70-80%) or replaced.

However, if a full replacement is required, they will repurpose the battery for some other use (battery storage for solar/wind etc1), or recycle. This has the added benefit of having value when removed and replace.

What about out of the 100,000 mile warranty?

There have been some cases where it has been called out as prohibitively expensive, and you would be right, if you went straight to a main dealer.

This is the equivalent of going to a main dealer for an out-of-warranty engine replacement (in this case, £9000, £12000 and £6500!)

Just like with a refurbished engine replacement (much cheaper), refurbished batteries do exist, and EV breaker yards , alongside independent EV garages are popping up to supply, but also fitting reconditioned or salvage packs

One huge advantage of this, is that a battery upgrade can also give another advantage of improving the original range of the vehicle, especially if larger batteries were made for that platform.

For example, there have been Nissan LEAFs that have gone from an original 24kWh to 62kWh. This is not inexpensive at the moment (24kWh to 62kWh is around £12,500 including fitting) .

This is definitely not cost effective given that a Leaf can be had for less than £4000. However, your Leaf will be in effect upgraded from a reasonable 80 miles to over 250 miles in a couple hours. This can even be a DIY repair, if you are in that mindset (and does not require a vehicle ramp).

In the case of Dala’s EV Repair 3NFG}”], DIY was £1800 equivalent, with a 24kWh to 30kWh replacement. This did involve selling the original battery pack as a DIY stationary storage device.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, EV batteries are certainly lasting longer than 3 years, are warrantied to 8 years and 100,000 miles. When buying a 3-4 year old EV (which is more likely than new), there is not much to worry about.

Finally, when you inevitably need a replacement (once your vehicle has gone beyond 100,000 miles or beyond 13-14 years of average usage), although the equivalent of a new engine replacement in price, replacement is certainly possible.

The main issue with this information is that battery pricing is coming down by leaps and bounds – it is and will likely be impossible and unrepresentative to determine the cost of a battery in a EV bought in 2024 by the time the battery actually warrants a replacement, using current pricing.

FYI: If you want some anecdotal evidence on this, my car has reached 60,000 miles2 as of this update, and is at 86% SOH, and still kicking!

Video Playlist:

Bibliography

1
C. Reid, Electric Car Batteries Lasting Longer Than Predicted Delays Recycling Programs, https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2022/08/01/electric-car-batteries-lasting-longer-than-predicted-delays-recycling-programs/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Fully Charged Show, New Batteries for Old EVs : 150% more range for a Nissan LEAF | FULLY CHARGED, 2021.
1
Battery Upgrades - Cleevely Electric Vehicles Gloucestershire, https://www.cleevelyev.co.uk/battery-upgrades/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
HEVRA, HEVRA, https://hevra.org.uk/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
EV Breakers - Vehicle Breakers - Dismantlers & Used Parts Specialists, https://www.evbreakers.com/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
James and Kate - The EV Team, Nissan Leaf 40kWh Fried Battery Teardown and Repair., 2021.
1
Fifth Gear, Can You Restore Lost Power To An Old Engine? #TBT - Fifth Gear, 2016.
1
Ford EcoBoost Nightmare | What’s happening with the replacement of engines that have failed are ford still offering replacement engines my 2016 plate eco boost just gone bang... | Facebook, https://www.facebook.com/groups/FordEcoboostNightmare/posts/3595192630750604/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Velar Forums, Velar ingenium engine needs replacing!!!, https://www.velarforums.co.uk/threads/velar-ingenium-engine-needs-replacing.4614/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Disco Sport Forums, Disastrous Ingenium Engine problem. Help needed!, https://www.discosportforums.co.uk/threads/disastrous-ingenium-engine-problem-help-needed.12051/, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
L. Najman, New Study, https://www.recurrentauto.com/research/how-long-do-ev-batteries-last, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
BMW UK, BMW i Warranty Guidelines | Warranties | BMW UK, https://www.bmw.co.uk/en/topics/owners/service-workshop/warranties/bmw-i-warranty-guidelines.html, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
MG Motor UK, Warranty | My MG | MG MOTOR UK, https://www.mg.co.uk/warranty, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Volkswagen, Electric Battery Maintenance and Warranty | Volkswagen UK, https://www.volkswagen.co.uk/en/electric-and-hybrid/should-you-go-electric/servicing/battery-maintenance-and-waranty.html, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Nissan, Car Warranty, https://www.nissan.co.uk/owners/car-warranty.html, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
Tesla, Vehicle Warranty | Tesla Support United Kingdom, https://www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/vehicle-warranty, (accessed 13 April 2024).
1
E. Yuraday, A Study on Real-Life Tesla Battery Deterioration | NimbleFins, https://www.nimblefins.co.uk/study-real-life-tesla-battery-deterioration, (accessed 12 April 2024).
1
Britannia Car Leasing, What is the average annual car mileage in the UK?, https://www.britanniacarleasing.co.uk/news/annual-uk-car-milage/, (accessed 12 April 2024).

34 thoughts on “Battery Health: The FUD, and the Truth”

  1. Pingback: levitra medication

  2. Pingback: mirtazapine 15 mg price

  3. Pingback: diflucan generic price

  4. Pingback: furosemide

  5. Pingback: vidalista 20mg reddit

  6. Pingback: buy levitra cheap

  7. Pingback: finasteride (proscar) drug class

  8. Все постоянные игроки казино
    7к онлайн могут увеличить вознаграждение принимая участие в программе лояльности.

  9. Ущерб от наркотиков — этто комплексная проблема, охватывающая физиологическое,
    психологическое (а) также общественное здоровье человека.

    Утилизация подобных наркотиков, яко кокаин, мефедрон,
    гашиш, «шишки» или «бошки»,
    что ль привести к неконвертируемым результатам как чтобы организма,
    так равно чтобы среды в течение
    целом. Но хоть при выковывании связи возможно восстановление —
    ядро, чтобы зависимый человек направился за помощью.
    Эпохально запоминать, яко наркозависимость лечится, равным образом реабилитация дает шанс сверху новую жизнь.

  10. Покер-рум доступен всем зарегистрированным пользователям с положительным балансом
    игрового счета.

  11. Ущерб от наркотиков — этто единая хоботня,
    обхватывающая физиологическое, психологическое также
    общественное здоровье человека.
    Утилизация подобных наркотиков, как кокаин, мефедрон, ямба, «наркотик» или «бошки», что ль родить ко неконвертируемым результатам
    как чтобы организма, яко (а) также для
    общества в целом. Но даже при вырабатывании связи возможно восстановление — главное, чтоб зависимый явантроп устремился за помощью.

    Важно помнить, яко наркозависимость лечится, а
    также реабилитация бабахает шансище сверху новую жизнь.

  12. В каталоге казино насчитывается более 200 уникальных онлайн-игр.

  13. Игроки могут запускать слоты, настольные игры и участвовать в акциях без
    ограничений.

  14. Это делает процесс игры более социальным и увлекательным, добавляя элемент живого общения и взаимодействия.

  15. Порча от наркотиков — этто сложная проблема, обхватывающая физическое, психологическое также социальное состояние здоровья человека.

    Употребление подобных наркотиков,
    как снежок, мефедрон, гашиш, «шишки» или «бошки», что ль обусловить
    к необратимым результатам яко чтобы организма, так равным образом чтобы общества на целом.
    Хотя хоть при вырабатывании зависимости
    возможно электровосстановление — ядро,
    чтобы зависимый человек обернулся согласен помощью.

    Важно помнить, что наркомания лечится, а также оправдание бабахает
    шанс сверху новую жизнь.

  16. Pingback: sildenafil citrate tablets ip 25 mg uses in pregnancy

  17. Ущерб от наркотиков — это комплексная хоботня,
    обхватывающая физиологическое, психологическое и
    общественное здоровье человека.
    Употребление таковских наркотиков, яко
    кокаин, мефедрон, ямба, «шишки» чи «бошки»,
    может огласить буква необратимым результатам как для организма,
    так равным образом чтобы общества на целом.
    Но даже при развитии зависимости эвентуально
    электровосстановление — главное,
    чтобы зависимый человек обернулся
    за помощью. Важно помнить, что наркомания врачуется, и восстановление
    в правах бабахает шансище сверху свежую
    жизнь.

  18. Pingback: generic cialis pills

  19. Pingback: acyclovir injection near me

  20. Pingback: bupropion xl 150mg diarrhea

  21. Как только процедуры отыгрыша будет завершена –
    деньги с бонусного счета будут переведены на
    основной, но не более суммы полученной
    ранее награды.

  22. Pingback: terbinafine side effects details

  23. Pingback: ivermectin adult parasite activity

  24. Thank you for sharing these well-reasoned and logical observations. The objective presentation makes it extremely easy to process the information and understand the big picture.

    kinghills

  25. Pingback: ivermectin topical pharmacokinetics

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top